Post Anyway: 4 Mindset Shifts That Changed My LinkedIn Game

After five years of posting on LinkedIn nearly every day - roughly 1,500 posts in total - I've seen firsthand what works, what doesn't, and most importantly, the mental barriers that prevent fractional executives from building a powerful presence on the platform.

Today, I'm breaking down the four most common mindset mistakes I see holding professionals back from LinkedIn success. If you've struggled to gain traction or even start posting consistently, you'll likely recognize at least one of these limiting beliefs in yourself.

Mindset Mistake #1: Chasing Virality

"I need my posts to go viral for this to be worth my time."

This might be the most pervasive misconception about LinkedIn. When we focus on virality or even high engagement numbers, we're optimizing for the wrong metrics entirely.

Let me share a telling example: I once worked with a recruiter who wanted to mimic another recruiter's "successful" LinkedIn strategy. The person she wanted to emulate was getting thousands of likes and comments - but there was a critical problem. All of his viral content was targeting job seekers, while my client made money by placing candidates with companies.

I asked her: "Would you rather have 1,000 likes from job seekers or 10 likes from decision-makers at companies who might hire you?"

The answer was obvious. Those 10 meaningful engagements from potential clients were infinitely more valuable than thousands of reactions from people who would never hire her services.

Here's the truth about virality: it's largely unpredictable. My most viral post ever - one that generated 750,000 impressions - was something I wrote in 15 minutes without much thought. Meanwhile, carefully crafted posts I spent hours on barely gained traction.

The Better Approach: Focus on consistency and speaking directly to your ideal clients. Meaningful engagement from the right people will generate more business than viral posts that reach the wrong audience.

Mindset Mistake #2: "I'm Just Contributing to the Noise"

"LinkedIn is all noise, and I don't have anything unique to say."

Nearly every client I've worked with has expressed this concern at some point. This mindset guarantees failure because it leads to generic, forgettable content that blends in with everything else.

Here's what most people miss: Nobody in the world has your unique combination of experiences, skills, successes, failures, and insights. When you share from a first-person perspective, you're creating content that literally no one else could produce.

The more specific, detailed, and niche your insights, the more valuable and distinct they become. Generic advice is everywhere - your specific experiences aren't.

For example, a generic post about "the importance of marketing analytics" gets lost in the noise. But when you detail how you implemented a specific attribution model for a DTC company that allowed them to identify their highest-ROI channel and grow 10x in two years? That's content that builds trust and generates client interest.

The Better Approach: Lean into your uniqueness. Share specific situations, decisions, mistakes, and successes from your career. The details aren't just interesting - they establish your expertise and help potential clients envision how you could help them.

Mindset Mistake #3: Fear-Driven Perfectionism

"What if my post is stupid? What if people don't like it or leave negative comments?"

This fear manifests in three ways:

• Never posting at all
• Posting very infrequently (when you gather enough courage)
• Spending hours perfecting each post, trying to move it from 90% to 100% ready

Here's the liberating truth: If your post doesn't resonate, virtually no one will see it. LinkedIn's algorithm quickly buries content that doesn't generate engagement. That "bad post" simply disappears into the digital abyss with minimal visibility.

Conversely, posts you might consider mediocre could unexpectedly resonate with your audience. We're generally poor judges of which content will perform well - if we weren't, everyone's posts would go viral all the time.

I have nearly 24,000 followers, and I've published posts that received zero engagement. Did it feel great? No. Did it matter in the long run? Not at all. I simply wrote another post the next day and moved on.

The Better Approach: Give yourself permission to be imperfect. Publish content that's 80% ready rather than striving for perfection. Use the time you save to create more content and get more "reps" in. Every post is a learning opportunity - either about what works or what doesn't.

Mindset Mistake #4: "I Have to Mimic Top Influencers"

"I need to copy what the popular LinkedIn personalities are doing to succeed."

While it's valuable to study effective content formats - proper spacing, hook lines, and structures - attempting to mimic someone else's voice or personality is a losing strategy.

Your unique perspective is your greatest asset. When you try to sound like someone else, you dilute what makes you distinctive and compelling.

I've been posting consistently for years, and the result is that I haven't had to introduce myself on a sales call in over two years. People already know my philosophies, strategies, and thinking because they've consumed my content. That familiarity creates trust that can't be bought or manufactured.

Countless prospects have told me, "There are lots of companies with similar offers, but I want to work with you because I trust you." That trust comes from consistently showing up as my authentic self, not from mimicking what works for others.

The Better Approach: Study content structure and format, but maintain your authentic voice. Trust that your experiences and insights are valuable when shared genuinely.

The Recovery From Mistakes Is Quick

If fear of negative reactions is holding you back, consider this: I once wrote a post about launching Uber Eats in Italy and cultural differences in working styles. Despite my efforts to be sensitive and objective, about 30-40 Italians took offense and attacked me in the comments.

It felt terrible in the moment. I did some damage control by editing the post and responding thoughtfully. And then - it was over. Within a week, no one was talking about it anymore. The entire "crisis" disappeared without lasting impact.

For most of us with modest followings, even our worst LinkedIn moments are quickly forgotten. The potential upside of consistent posting far outweighs these minor risks.

The Compounding Effect of Consistency

When you post daily or nearly daily, the impact compounds dramatically. With an average of 1,000-2,000 impressions per post, seven posts weekly generate 30,000-40,000 monthly impressions. Over time, this visibility creates familiarity and trust with your audience.

The real power isn't in any single post - it's in the relationship you build through consistent presence. You're giving people the opportunity to know you, understand your thinking, and develop trust without ever having a direct conversation.

Your Action Plan

If these mindset barriers resonate with you, here's how to move forward:

1. Commit to consistency over perfection. Schedule time to create content regularly, and publish it even when it doesn't feel perfect.
2. Focus on your ideal clients, not the broadest possible audience. Would you rather have 10 potential clients or 1,000 irrelevant views?
3. Share specific experiences rather than generic insights. The details of your unique journey are what build trust and demonstrate expertise.
4. Keep posts simple but effective. Use good formatting, compelling hooks, and clear value—but don't spend hours perfecting each post.
5. Prepare for occasional criticism but know that its impact is temporary. Even negative interactions fade quickly.

The most powerful LinkedIn strategy isn't about viral posts or copying influencers - it's about consistently showing up as your authentic self and providing value to your ideal audience. When you do that, you build a foundation of trust that makes selling your services dramatically easier.

What mindset barrier has been holding you back from LinkedIn success? Identifying it is the first step toward breaking through.

Mylance

‍This value-added article was written by Mylance. Mylance takes your marketing completely off your hands. We build the marketing machine that your Fractional Business needs, but you don't have time to run. So it operates daily, growing your brand, completely done for you.Instead of dangling numbers in front of you, our approach focuses on precise and thoughtful input: targeted outreach to the right decision makers, compelling messaging that resonates, and content creation that establishes trust and legitimacy.To apply for access, submit an application and we'll evaluate your fit for the service. If you’re not ready for lead generation, we also have a free, vetted community for top fractional talent that includes workshops, a rates database, networking, and a lot of free resources to support your fractional business.